The Private BankerSaturday, November 21, 2026

JPMorgan, Morgan Stanley Contest Shareholder Suits Over Buyout Advisory Roles

Banks face Delaware Chancery Court claims that they aided undervalued sales to private-equity clients after a corporate-law change left financial advisers exposed to liability.

contemporary skyscrapers in financial district on overcast day
Photo by wewe yang on Pexels.com

JPMorgan Chase & Co. and Morgan Stanley are defending shareholder lawsuits in Delaware Chancery Court alleging that the banks assisted in multibillion-dollar buyouts that undervalued public company shares for the benefit of private-equity clients with which the banks maintain business relationships. Plaintiffs contend the institutions knew their actions supported directors in breaching fiduciary duties by steering transactions toward favored buyers at inadequate prices, according to the complaints.

A revision to Delaware corporate law enacted last year, prompted in part by high-profile reincorporations including Tesla Inc.’s move to Texas, raised the bar for suits against executives and directors in certain insider transactions. The changes did not extend equivalent protections to financial advisers, leaving banks as potential defendants for plaintiffs seeking alternative avenues after a separate court setback involving Goldman Sachs Group Inc. earlier this year.

JPMorgan and Morgan Stanley have each confronted two such actions, with one suit against each bank previously dismissed. JPMorgan has moved to dismiss a remaining case asserting it assisted Hellman & Friedman in exiting its stake in Snap One Holdings Corp. through a sale that disadvantaged public stockholders. The bank described the process as bearing “all the hallmarks of a legitimate and well-executed sale process.” The underlying Snap One transaction involved a $1.4 billion merger with Resideo Technologies Inc. completed in 2024.

Morgan Stanley faces a newly filed lawsuit concerning its advisory role in the $1.5 billion acquisition of database software company Couchbase Inc. by Austin-based private equity firm Haveli Investments. Shareholders allege the bank’s involvement facilitated a process that failed to maximize value for public holders.

Corporate attorney Gail Weinstein of Fried, Frank, Harris, Shriver & Jacobson noted that the litigation risk provides banks an additional incentive for carefulness, resulting in greater emphasis on early and ongoing disclosure of conflicts to boards and more detailed context for fees received from bidders.

While the suits portray banks as active facilitators of undervalued deals favoring private-equity relationships, the banks have successfully obtained dismissal of prior comparable actions, indicating that Delaware courts have not uniformly accepted the aiding-and-abetting theories advanced by plaintiffs. JPMorgan’s motion in the Snap One matter emphasizes the presence of standard sale-process features, including competitive dynamics and independent board consideration, which courts have previously found sufficient to defeat similar claims. The Delaware law revision, although limited in scope for advisers, has coincided with heightened judicial scrutiny of conflict disclosures rather than automatic liability findings against financial institutions. Public filings related to the Couchbase transaction show Morgan Stanley rendered a fairness opinion supporting the $24.50 per-share cash price, a 29 percent premium to the pre-announcement closing price and a 67 percent premium to an earlier reference date.

The Snap One complaint, originally filed under seal and later unsealed, named both JPMorgan Securities LLC and Moelis & Co. as advisers alongside Hellman & Friedman affiliates and former board members, alleging the private-equity firm’s voting control created an “iron grip” on the process. Couchbase’s proxy materials detail that Morgan Stanley reviewed potential financial sponsors and strategic acquirors, relayed multiple bids, and delivered an oral fairness opinion later confirmed in writing on June 20, 2025. The $1.5 billion Couchbase deal included a go-shop period that expired without a superior proposal. Delaware Chancery Court has required increasingly granular disclosure of adviser relationships with bidders and fee structures in recent rulings, elevating the documentation burden for banks even in the absence of liability findings.

Enjoyed this article? Access ready-to-use chart frameworks combined with training content and market research to apply it on any market by investing in a membership.