
Canadian heavy crude is trading at its steepest discount to US benchmark prices since 2018. Western Canada Select for December delivery at Hardisty, Alberta, settled at $27 a barrel below West Texas Intermediate on Monday, Nov. 2, in CalRock assessments, compared with a gap of $29.75 on Friday. The discount is now more than double its September level and topped $30 at points in late October.
The widening reaches the US Gulf Coast. Canadian heavy barrels there are changing hands at discounts of more than $20 a barrel to WTI, and differentials at Houston are wider than the previous record of $20.60 a barrel set in October 2022.
The move came as the broader oil market swung sharply. Crude fell more than 7% on Monday after talks between Iranian and Qatari officials raised hopes of an end to the US-Israeli war with Iran and a more stable Middle East supply outlook.
Monday also opened the main Canadian crude trading cycle, which runs from the first day of each month until the day before pipeline nominations are due. Most Canadian physical trade is priced in that window, so the December assessments set the reference for the bulk of the month’s volumes.
The cause differs from earlier episodes. Past blowouts, including in 2018, followed shortages of pipeline space out of the Western Canadian Sedimentary Basin. Analyst Rory Johnston, founder of the Commodity Context newsletter, said this widening has nothing to do with pipeline capacity. He pointed instead to high global freight rates that have cut demand for Canadian barrels re-exported from the Gulf Coast to overseas buyers.
Tanker rates climbed after attacks on commercial vessels during the Iran conflict, raising the cost of moving Gulf Coast cargoes abroad. Johnston also said the US Gulf Coast market for heavy, high-sulfur fuel oil is oversupplied because refineries are running at full capacity, which weighs on the value of heavy feedstock.
Competition for refinery slots is a second pressure. Heavy Venezuelan crude is flowing to US refiners equipped to process dense, sour grades, the same plants that traditionally take Canadian barrels.
The higher benchmark prices that followed the Middle East disruption have therefore passed through to Canadian producers only in part. A wider differential means oil sands producers without their own refining capacity realize less per barrel for a given WTI price, while integrated companies with downstream assets can offset part of the upstream hit through cheaper feedstock.
The expanded Trans Mountain pipeline, which carries crude to the Pacific coast, offers access to Asian markets. Capacity alone does not offset global freight costs or shifts in refinery demand, the factors now driving the gap.
Other benchmarks put the discount wider still. On a monthly-average basis, the gap in Alberta reached about $31.70 a barrel early Tuesday, the widest since November 2018. The figures use different pricing conventions and are not directly comparable with the $27 settlement.
Sources: boereport.com, oilandgas360.com, Bloomberg.








